← All articles
Italy fines Meta 805 million euros over Android photo access without specific consent
AI News

Italy fines Meta 805 million euros over Android photo access without specific consent

Italy's data protection authority found Facebook's gallery suggestions feature read Android users' photos and videos without specific consent.

Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, announced on Saturday, November 14, 2026 that it has fined Meta 805 million euros. It is the largest fine the Italian regulator has ever imposed on a big tech company. The issue is not about AI, but about something closer to daily life: the photos on your phone.

1. What happened

The "camera roll suggestions" feature in the Facebook app for Android suggests photos and videos from a user's phone gallery as ideas for posts. According to the Garante's statement, Meta accessed Italian users' photographs, videos and related metadata without obtaining specific consent and without properly informing them.

The investigation began in 2025. The authority found Facebook requested gallery access through a single permission covering the entire app. The notice before it was generic, so users did not realise they were also authorising suggestions based on their gallery photos.

2. How many people were affected

The Garante estimates around 20 million Android users in Italy were affected. The authority cited the high number of people affected and the duration of the infringement as factors in the fine's size, along with Meta's lack of cooperation during the investigation.

The dollar conversion differs between reports. Reuters reported 887 million dollars, AFP reported 880 million dollars. Reuters stated the fine equals about 0.47% of the group's global revenue, while AFP stated roughly 0.4% of annual turnover, with Meta's 2025 revenue at 201 billion dollars.

3. Meta says it will appeal

A Meta spokesperson said the company strongly disagrees with the assessment of the facts, the application of the law and what it called the disproportionate level of the fine, and that it plans to appeal. According to the spokesperson, this is a straightforward feature that helps people post photos and videos to Facebook, and people must grant permission on their device before it can operate, and can change that permission at any time in settings.

The authority also rejected Meta's objection that the case belonged under the Irish regulator's jurisdiction, because the EU ePrivacy regulation does not provide the one-stop-shop mechanism.

4. What Meta must do within 60 days

Meta has 60 days to do three things. Disable the gallery suggestions feature by default, including for users who already authorised it. Request consent separately and specifically for that feature. Clearly explain what it does, namely that it involves access to the photo gallery, and how to turn it off.

5. There is an AI angle, but it is outside this case

The investigation did not cover the possible use of gallery content to train AI models, a practice Meta denied. Reuters reported this explicitly, so do not read this fine as a penalty for AI training. It is a penalty for how permission was requested and what users were told.

For context on Italian tech fines, AFP notes the previous largest was more than 1.1 billion euros against Amazon in 2021 for breaching competition law, later reduced to 752 million euros on appeal. BBC calls the Meta fine among the largest an Italian authority has ever imposed on a tech company.

What it means for you

The fine comes from Italy, but the lesson applies anywhere, including Malaysia. A single-line app permission can open up far more than you expect.

  1. Check your phone's gallery permissions. Open app settings, look for Photos permission, and ask whether that app really needs your entire gallery.
  2. One permission is not full disclosure. A single popup can cover several different functions. Read what is being requested before tapping allow.
  3. You can revoke it at any time. Permission is not permanent. Change it in device settings without deleting the app.
  4. Watch automatic suggestion features. A feature that "helps" you with content from your phone usually needs active access to your files.

Sources